Agri-Fab 45-0463 and EarthWay T150 are two of the most reliable tow-behind broadcast spreaders for tackling large lawns, gardens, and fields. While both are designed for efficiency and durability, they cater to slightly different needs. In this comparison, we’ll break down their features, performance, and overall value to help you decide which spreader is the right fit for your lawn care tasks.
What are the capacity and coverage differences?
The Agri-Fab 45-0463 holds up to 130 lbs, providing coverage for about half an acre before needing a refill. Its spread width reaches approximately 12 feet, helping reduce passes across larger lawns.
The EarthWay T150 accommodates 150 lbs, which means less frequent stops to reload. Coverage width averages 8 feet, slightly narrower but designed to improve accuracy when working near edges, fences, or delicate landscaping.
How does construction and durability compare?
Agri-Fab uses a rustproof poly hopper paired with a steel frame for strength. An enclosed gearbox with aluminum gears is included for longer life and smoother spreading.
EarthWay builds the T150 with an epoxy-coated steel frame, offering stronger resistance to wear. Its gearbox and all-metal gate lever are heavier-duty, appealing to users who require a spreader for frequent or commercial-level use.
How do tires and maneuverability differ?
Agri-Fab fits the 45-0463 with 12-inch pneumatic tires. These provide good balance and traction across most suburban lawns and moderate terrain.
EarthWay equips the T150 with large 12″ x 3.5″ knobby tires. These excel on uneven ground, slopes, or rougher surfaces where standard pneumatic tires may bounce and affect spread consistency.
How easy are they to use?
Agri-Fab’s tow-behind spreader connects quickly with a hitch pin and operates with a steel control lever that resists bending. The design is straightforward, making it a dependable choice for homeowners.
EarthWay enhances user comfort with adjustable-height T-handles, uncommon in tow-behind models. Precision side spread control also makes it easier to limit waste by keeping material inside boundaries.
What are the price and value differences?
Agri-Fab positions the 45-0463 as an affordable option for homeowners seeking reliability without overcomplicating lawn care. The wider spread width increases efficiency, especially on larger lawns.
EarthWay T150 usually comes at a higher price point, but durability, precise spreading, and comfort features justify the added investment. It is well-suited for larger or more demanding jobs where performance matters more than budget.
Agri-Fab 45-0463 130 lb. vs EarthWay T150 150 lb. Tow Behind Broadcast Spreader Comparison
Choosing between the Agri-Fab 45-0463 and the EarthWay T150 depends on how much ground needs coverage, the type of material, and the precision required. Both tow-behind spreaders are highly rated for fertilizers, grass seed, and similar products, but they differ in capacity, spread width, and build quality. This review breaks down the details to help decide which model is the better fit.
| Feature | Agri-Fab 45-0463 | EarthWay T150 |
|---|---|---|
| Hopper Capacity | 130 lbs | 150 lbs |
| Spreading Width | 12 feet | ~8 feet |
| Frame Material | Poly hopper, steel frame | Epoxy-coated steel frame |
| Gearbox | Enclosed with aluminum gears | Heavy-duty gearbox |
| Tires | 12-inch pneumatic | 12" x 3.5" knobby |
| Weight | 35–37 lbs | ~25 lbs |
| Adjustability | Fixed handle | Adjustable T-handles |
| Warranty / Durability | 3-year limited warranty | Commercial-grade durability |
| Price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
My Recommendation
Agri-Fab 45-0463 is the best choice for homeowners with large, flat lawns who value affordability and efficiency in each pass. EarthWay T150 is better suited for professionals or property owners managing uneven terrain or needing more precision. Both models are strong performers but cater to different types of users.
Which model gives more accurate spread pattern at different granule sizes?
EarthWay T150 is more accurate with smaller or lighter granules thanks to its precision controls. Agri-Fab handles coarser materials effectively but may scatter finer particles less evenly.
How do tire types and sizes compare for rough terrain performance?
EarthWay’s knobby tires outperform Agri-Fab on rough terrain, offering stronger grip and stability. Agri-Fab’s pneumatic tires are reliable on flat or moderately bumpy lawns but less steady on uneven ground.
What are the gearbox and drive mechanism differences?
Agri-Fab 45-0463 features an enclosed gearbox with aluminum gears and a steel rod lever. EarthWay T150 uses a heavy-duty gearbox with reinforced internals and a robust all-metal gate lever for longer service life.
What towing speed and gate settings work for 50 lb/ft² application?
Agri-Fab spreads well at 2–3 mph with the gate set around three-quarters open. EarthWay T150 achieves better precision at closer to 2 mph, with the gate adjusted between half and three-quarters depending on material type.
